Joe Machota

Graduation Year

1993

Millikin major: Musical Theatre

Other degrees: Master’s degree in music, The Boston Conservatory, 1995

Current employment: Since 2005, talent agent at CAA (Creative Artists Agency) and named head of the agency’s theater department in 2013. Machota has represented many well-known Broadway, television, and movie actors including: Scarlett Johansson, Jim Parsons, Jane Fonda, Neil Patrick Harris, Chris Pine, Ricky Martin, Zachary Quinto, Ian McKellen and Michelle Williams.

Activities as a student at MU: At Millikin, Machota had lead roles in several productions, including “George M,” “Tartuffe,” “On the Town” and “Company.” He received the Ron Smith Award for excellence in musical theatre in 1993.

Accomplishments since graduating from MU: Recipient of Millikin’s 2003 Young Alumnus Award, Machota was a member of the original Broadway cast of the critically acclaimed “Mamma Mia!” from 2000-2003, originating the role of Sky. Machota starred in the lead role of Ren in the first national tour of “Footloose” from October 1998 through January 2000 and also starred as Joseph in the national touring production of “Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat,” which made a stop at Kirkland Fine Arts Center in 1997. He also performed the role of Tulsa in “Gypsy” with Betty Buckley and Deborah Gibson in 1998, and he originated the role of Laurie in a 2001 pre-Broadway workshop of “Little Women – the Musical” and starred in the 2001 tour of the newly restaged “Leader of the Pack.” Machota took over the lead role in the Las Vegas MGM Grand production of the Andrew Lloyd Webber musical “EFX” after actor Michael Crawford was injured, and he went on to perform and understudy the role for more than five months before eventually leaving to star in “Joseph.”

Machota was a 2001 nominee for the Broadway Audience Award as best featured actor in a musical for “Mamma Mia!” and was nominated for several awards across the country for his portrayal of Ren in “Footloose.”

Who is your most memorable MU professor or staff member and why? In a 2012 Millikin Quarterly article, Machota credited Millikin professors with helping him become a stronger, more versatile performer, which in turn aided him in his transition from the stage to his current career as an agent. "I cannot rave enough about the faculty at Millikin," he said. "From [faculty members] Lynn Snyder to Barry Pearson, Laura Ledford and David Golden - they're amazing. I also appreciate Darlene Harshbarger and Gary Shull, who taught dance. I was not a gifted dancer! We all know our strengths, but they really helped me work on my weaknesses. Their emphasis on being a well-rounded performer was such a huge help to me."


Agent of Change

This 1993 alum has twice been named one the 50 Most Powerful People on Broadway.

by Margaret Friend  |  Published in the spring 2012 issue of Millikin Quarterly magazine.

After earning his master's degree at the prestigious Boston Conservatory of Music in 1995, Joe Machota ’93 began a successful career in musical theatre (see list below). Yet after 10 years of starring in Vegas productions, national touring company musicals and Broadway hits, Machota turned away from the spotlight to begin a new career as a talent agent.

"Understanding the business side of musical theatre is how I continued to work," Machota explains. "I've always felt that my real strengths are my networking and people skills."

So, while singing and dancing his way through "Mamma Mia" on Broadway each night, Machota interned at a friend's talent agency during the day. Even though his day job paid only $100 a week, Machota says after his second week interning, "I knew this was what I wanted."

Although his friend offered to hire him full-time, he decided to pursue a job with Creative Artists Agency (CAA), a prominent talent agency representing entertainment and sports figures.

"They were planning to expand their New York office and wanted to hire someone with knowledge of theatre," Machota says. "I applied online and was hired six weeks later."

Starting in their lowest-paid position as a floater, Machota was told there would be no opportunity for him to go through CAA's training program to become an agent, meaning he would have no chance to work with the agency's clients. But within a year, he earned his way into the training program and after just eight months as a trainee, he was working as an agent. In 2010 and again in 2011, he was included in the list of Broadway's 50 Most Powerful People on BroadwaySpotted (a social networking site devoted to theatre), and was also named to Out magazine's 2010 "Out 100" list of influential LGBT members.

Now, Machota excels at helping clients win the type of plum roles he once sought. Working in CAA's talent department, he strives to create the perfect partnership, mating performers currently under agency contract with theatre projects looking for just the right person to fill a role.

But he's also on the lookout for fresh faces to bring on board. "Part of my job is keeping an eye out for talented people who would be a good fit for our agency," he says.

What made Machota such a good fit as a talent agent? He firmly believes the education and experience he gained at Millikin are the keys to his success.

"In some ways, I've never worked as hard as I did while I was a student at Millikin," he says. "Those professors work you 24/7, and that's such a great training ground for the real world … it's really paid off for me."

Machota also credits Millikin professors with helping him become a stronger, more versatile performer, which in turn aided him in his transition from the stage to his new career. "I cannot rave enough about the faculty at Millikin," he says. "From [faculty members] Lynn Snyder to Barry Pearson, Laura Ledford and David Golden - they're amazing. I also appreciate Darlene Harshbarger and Gary Shull, who taught dance. I was not a gifted dancer! We all know our strengths, but they really helped me work on my weaknesses. Their emphasis on being a well-rounded performer was such a huge help to me."

In an effort to "pay it forward," Machota has returned to campus as a guest artist, speaking with students and faculty about careers in musical theatre. "Musical theatre is a competitive landscape, and Millikin provides a healthy way to prepare for the real world," he says.

"There's constantly something to audition for - lots of productions are going on all the time and you're encouraged to perform from your first year. When you graduate, you're so prepared for all the auditions and competition required to get a job."

In recognition of his loyalty to Millikin and in celebration of his successful career, he was named Young Alumnus of the Year in 2003.

"My most treasured award is the Young Alumnus Award I received from Millikin," Machota says. "To have that recognition from a place I so cherish means so much to me."


Joe Machota's theatre credits include:

  • 1996 hired to understudy Michael Crawford in the MGM Grand production, "EFX," in Las Vegas.
  • 1996 left "EFX" to star as Joseph in a touring production of "Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat."
  • 1998 traded his coat of many colors for a pair of dancing shoes, starring in the lead role of "Ren" in the first national tour of the musical, "Footloose."
  • 2001 originated the role of "Sky" in the Broadway production of "Mamma Mia."